pile of books
skip main nav
 Ling 131: Language & Style
 

 Topic 12 - Meaning between the lines (Session A) > Top Girls > Task A skip topic navigation

Session Overview
Inference and the Discourse Architecture of Drama
Grice's Cooperative Principle
Practising Gricean Analysis
Top Girls
Conversational implicature and The Dumb Waiter
Gricean Self-Test
 
Useful Links
Readings
 

Top Girls

Task A - Initial engagement with the text

Read the text below and then watch the videoclip performance. After you feel you have come to terms with the extract, write down what you feel, in general terms, is the 'subtext' of the relationship between the characters Win and Louise. What feelings and attitudes come through what is said?

[Context: Win works as an adviser at the Top Girls employment agency, helping people find employment. Louise has come to the agency for help, and this is the first meeting between the two women.]

1. WIN:

Now, Louise, hello. I have your details here. You've been very loyal to the one job I see.

2. LOUISE:

Yes I have.

3. WIN:

Twenty years is a long time in one place.

4. LOUISE:

I feel it is. I feel it's time to move on.

5. WIN:

And you are what age now?

6. LOUISE:

I'm in my early forties.

7. WIN:

Exactly?

8. LOUISE:

Forty-six.

9. WIN:

It's not necessarily a handicap. Well it is of course, we have to face that. But it's not necessarily a disabling handicap. Experience does count for something.

10. LOUISE:

I hope so.

11. WIN:

Now between ourselves is there any trouble, any reason why you're leaving that wouldn't appear on the form?

12. LOUISE:

Nothing like that.

13. WIN:

Like what?

14. LOUISE:

Nothing at all.

15. WIN:

No long term understandings come to a sudden end, making for an insupportable atmosphere?

16. LOUISE:

I've always completely avoided anything like that at all.

17. WIN:

No personality clashes with your immediate superiors or inferiors?

18. LOUISE:

I've always taken care to get on very well with everyone.

19. WIN:

I only ask because it can affect the reference and it also affects your motivation. I want to be quite clear why you're moving on. So I take it the job itself no longer satisfies you. Is it the money?

20. LOUISE:

It's partly the money. It's not so much the money.

21. WIN:

Nine thousand is very respectable. Have you dependants?

22. LOUISE:

No, no dependants. My mother died.

23. WIN:

So why are you making a change?

24. LOUISE:

Other people make changes.

25. WIN:

But why are you, now, after spending most of your life in one place?

(Top Girls, by Caryl Churchill, Act 2, Scene 3 - an interview at the employment agency)

video clip View 'Top Girls' video clip

 

Our answer

 


goto top of page
Next: Task B - Turns 1 - 4 next

Home ¦ Outline ¦ Contents ¦ Glossary