Matthew Saxton
John N Towse
Journal of Experimental Child Psychology, 1998, 69(1),
66-79
Differences between languages have been implicated recently in explanations
of the cross-cultural disparities observed in children's mathematical performance
on place value tasks (e.g. Miura, Okamoto, Kim, Chang, Steere, & Fayol,
1994). Children's understanding of place value was investigated here with
93 English-speaking children and 50 Japanese-speaking children (aged 6
and 7 years). Cubes denoting units and tens were made available to children
for producing representations of multi-digit numerals. It was found that
subtle shifts in task instructions produced a marked influence on children's
performance. In particular, differences between English and Japanese participants
disappeared when the use of ten cubes was demonstrated in practice trials.
More generally, the findings indicate that the influence of language on
the cognitive representaion of number is less direct than has previously
been suggested.