Creating more opportunities for young people does not need to be at the expense of secure work
Posted on
© Adobe Stock
The launch of the final report of the Milburn Review has turbo charged the national debate on how to support more young people into employment. With almost one million young people currently not in education, employment or training (NEET), the scale and urgency of the challenge is clear.
Alan Milburn is right that we need to see more job opportunities created for young people across the UK. But reforms will not succeed if they end up prioritising ‘any job’ over the creation of the secure work, that will be critical in helping those young people sustain employment.
Whilst discussions over the sequencing of the employment policy agenda are sensible, it would be a false logic to weaken any elements of the Employment Rights Act under the pretence of making it easier for employers to hire young people. The last two decades have seen insecure work become entrenched in the UK, with young people most exposed. Whilst symptoms and causes can be difficult to untangle, under this model of work, we have ended up with 13% of young people NEET.
This high level of disengagement from work is caused by a myriad of factors, as the Milburn Review so carefully unpacked and highlighted. What we know is it’s a long-standing problem and as such cannot be attributed to improvements to employment rights yet to take effect, and we must caution against rhetoric that does so.
Instead, Government should prioritise providing certainty to employers over where the final regulations will land. The Employment Rights Act has created the framework, but important details of implementation, including around guaranteed hours and notice of shifts, are still being settled.
A renewed focus on the Employment Rights Act
The Milburn Review is right to recognise that in many parts of the country, the labour market is failing to provide enough opportunities for young people to get their first foothold in employment. Previous Work Foundation analysis of online job ads has shown that the number of starter jobs available to young people has almost halved in the last decade and the challenges are particularly acute in places like the North East and East Midlands.
Figure 1: The availability of jobs per NEET young person and varies widely by English region
Source: Adzuna data, ONS NEET data, Department for Education NEET data, Oct-Dec 2025.
Unsurprisingly, this has rapidly given rise to renewed questions regarding the Government’s Employment Rights Act, and specifically the introduction of a new right to guaranteed hours, which is still being consulted on. Opponents of these reforms have seized on the Milburn Review to suggest these changes will further compound the employment challenges facing young people and should be paused or scrapped.
But this argument ignores the negative impact that the rise of insecure and precarious work is already having on the state of youth employment in the UK.
Our analysis shows that workers aged 16–24 are 2.2 times more likely than those aged 50–65 to be in severely insecure work. These jobs are characterised by combinations of low and unpredictable pay, insecure contracts, unpredictable hours, limited autonomy and weak access to employment protections. And this has a significant impact on incomes too - in 2023, workers in severely insecure jobs earned on average £63 less a week than those in secure work – a penalty of £3,276 a year.
Zero-hour contracts cause work-life chaos
Zero-hour contracts provide a particularly stark example of the negative impact insecure work can have, and it’s one that young people disproportionately bear the brunt of. Earlier this year, there were a record 1.24 million people employed on zero-hour contracts.
Our research has found that young workers aged 16–24 are more than five times as likely to be on a zero-hour contract as those aged 25 and over. Crucially, this cannot simply be explained by students looking for work around their studies. In 2025, more than three-quarters of people on zero-hour contracts (77%) were not in full-time education, while young workers who are not students have previously been found to be 3.6 times more likely to be on zero-hour contracts than workers across age groups.
Figure 2: Proportion of workers on zero-hour contracts, by age group

Source: Work Foundation calculations of Labour Force Survey microdata, 2023 AJ. These figures include full-time students.
Our recent research with people in zero-hour work found they are struggling with cancelled shifts, very short notice of changes and pressure to accept work because they feared losing future hours. Participants described the resulting “work-life chaos”, including difficulty organising childcare, uncertainty over household finances and anxiety about what their income would be from one week to the next.
This matters because insecure work is often not the stepping stone into better employment that it is sometimes assumed to be. Our longitudinal research which tracked the employment pathways of over 9,000 people found that 28.2% of young people aged 16-24 were in ‘long-term insecurity’ – meaning they remained in insecure work for four years or more. For many, insecurity can become a trap, rather than a bridge into a better job.
These problems have been acknowledged in the Netherlands, the country that much of the Milburn agenda learns from. As part of a package of reforms to improve employment conditions that commenced in 2023, earlier this year,the Dutch Senate approved legislation to ban zero-hour contracts and strictly limit the use of temporary contracts. The bill passed with a comfortable majority with the new rules taking effect in 2028. School pupils, students, and people past retirement age will still be able to opt into flexible work in some circumstances. In the UK, the plans also allow for carve outs, with all workers still be able to opt in to zero-hour work, if they choose to.
Poor quality work can also undermine health
Addressing labour market insecurity is particularly important given the changing nature of the youth NEET population.
Milburn is right to put health at the heart of the response. His final Review found that 48% of NEET respondents reported a long-term health condition, compared with 25% of young people in education, employment or training. Meanwhile, the latest Government data shows that 45.3% of NEET young people are classified as disabled.
For these young people, the quality of the job they move into matters enormously. The Work Foundation has found that workers with low levels of control over their work – including over working hours, pace and how tasks are undertaken – are 3.7 times more likely to leave work following a negative health experience. Workers with health conditions are also less likely to progress from insecure to secure employment.
This should fundamentally shape how we think about getting NEET young people into work. Many have already been outside the labour market for a significant period. They may need health support, vocational rehabilitation, training, confidence-building and help navigating recruitment. They also need employers willing to give them a first opportunity.
What young people do not need is a revolving door of low-paid, unpredictable jobs that makes it harder to manage their health, organise their lives or build the experience needed to progress. Not only is this churn bad for the young person, it creates big challenges for the new legal guarantee to work or training proposed in the Milburn agenda. If young people are cycling in and out of short-term insecure jobs, the opportunity for them to slip through the net is ever greater.
Employers need clarity on where reforms will land
The measures within the Government’s Employment Rights Act are part of the solution to the NEETs crisis. The Act’s measures on zero-hour contracts – including rights to guaranteed hours, reasonable notice of shifts and compensation when shifts are cancelled or curtailed at short notice – are designed precisely to tackle the worst forms of one-sided flexibility.
The sooner they can be issued, with a clear timeline of implementation, the sooner employers in sectors most likely to be affected can make workforce and recruitment plans for 2027 and beyond.
Job quality is vital to create a new settlement for the next generation
If Milburn is right that we need a structural response to the youth employment crisis, then the quality of the jobs young people move into is vital. More young people in work is a vital goal. But we need to think beyond the immediate NEET statistics, which show us a snapshot, not a life course. The lasting measure of success must be whether those jobs give young people a secure platform from which to build healthier, better-paid and more productive working lives.
Related Blogs
Disclaimer
The opinions expressed by our bloggers and those providing comments are personal, and may not necessarily reflect the opinions of Lancaster University. Responsibility for the accuracy of any of the information contained within blog posts belongs to the blogger.
Back to blog listing