Delivering Milburn’s Opportunity Guarantee: Why the UK needs a Community Jobs Fund
Posted on
© Adobe Stock
The Milburn Review is right to put employment support at the forefront of its response to the youth employment crisis. The impact of proposed interventions like cuts to employer national insurance contributions remain uncertain, and wider calls to rollback progress on minimum wages or employer rights risk trading short-term gains for the decent work that needs to be at the center of any new settlement.
But well-designed active labour market policies – those that comprise the ‘work side’ of the new Opportunity Guarantee – have a proven track-record of success, can help without the trade-offs, and can have an impact fast enough to matter to those out of work today.
Figure 1: Key employment-related interventions in the Opportunity Guarantee

The employment support identified by the Milburn Review builds on the government’s existing offering, such as the Youth Jobs Grant and Jobs Guarantee, but aims to expand coverage and intensify the value of support on offer to those with unique needs, such as managing a disability.
And the Youth Opportunity Service aims to create a single channel for accessing this support for both young people and employers.
Crucially, this type of support responds to the heart of the NEET crisis: the lack of available jobs.
But the new settlement promised by the Milburn Review is not just help to get a job, it is an Opportunity Guarantee. And a Guarantee will require a level of reliable job creation that the existing basket of incentives may struggle to deliver.
Employment incentives are always a gamble
Many of these complexities are best on display in the Youth Jobs Grant, an existing initiative that offers £3,000 to any employer hiring a qualifying NEET young person. The Milburn Review recommends expanding the reach of the grant, particularly by offering an extra premium of £2,000 to small businesses or those hiring young people with specific needs, such as those with disabilities.
The report views the Grant as “the main targeted hiring incentive for young people”, and has earmarked about 20% of the cost of the entire package of support to hiring incentives.
But the Milburn team also seem aware of the limits of these types of interventions. Only an estimated 60,000 young people per year are projected to benefit from the grant, and big questions remain on how many of these will represent legitimately new jobs.
The report itself highlights that surveys of previous beneficiaries of job grants indicate 72% of employers would have hired the same number of young people without support. This is in line with evaluations of past programmes like the Youth Contract, in which 76% of jobs were estimated to have been created anyway, and with estimates for the existing Youth Jobs Grant, where 86% of jobs supported may have existed without support. As the table below shows, this means the proportion of truly additional jobs tends to be fairly low.
Figure 2: Estimates of Job Grant Additionality (the share of jobs supported that would not have existed without support)

Note: Values for “Youth Jobs Grant (2026 – 2029, DWP Survey)” refer to the share of supported employers creating jobs that would not otherwise have existed. Other data points refer to the share of supported vacancies that would not otherwise have existed.
Source: Milburn Review, DWP, Resolution Foundation.
This track record demonstrates the very fine line employment incentives have to walk. At most levels of incentive, companies still take on the majority of wage costs, and their decisions are shaped by the same unchanged long-term considerations of business needs and sustainability. There are certainly cases where a wage subsidy can change a business' hiring plans. But more often than not, those plans are shaped by what work needs to be done, rather than by the fine margins of employment costs for underpaid young staff.
Those broader considerations are particularly challenging in the current labour market. In a Work Foundation survey completed in mid-2026, among employers who were participating or planning to participate in the Youth Jobs Grant, half (50%) had cut starter jobs in the last year, and three in five (61%) had invested in AI that reduced the number of entry-level jobs.
None of which is to say that initiatives like the Youth Jobs Grant aren’t worth exploring. There are many moments, places, and people for whom the grant might deliver. But keeping the promise of the Opportunity Guarantee will require making policy that can work everywhere, and that will demand more options than are currently on offer.
The Opportunity Guarantee needs a public backstop
For those who fall through the gaps between these employment incentives, one option might be for the government to directly create work. The Milburn Review already emphasises the value of this approach through its 13-week civic service programme, which offers out of work young people the chance to volunteer in meaningful community work like social care.
But volunteering is not an option for those who need a salary to get by, nor does it necessarily offer the types of sustained engagement that young people need to learn, and that cash-strapped communities require to meet their needs. The Work Foundation’s Community Jobs Fund (CJF) offers a different approach, employing young people in stable, decently paid work in the types of activities their communities need.
Figure 3: Key benefits of the Community Jobs Fund (CJF) as an employment backstop

This type of support offers government more control and may better meet Alan Milburn’s call for a stable system of long-term structural support to youth employment – something jobs grants cannot achieve without creating a permanent transfer from the fiscus to employers.
Crucially, it adds an intervention to the Opportunity Guarantee that we know can reliably create jobs in every postcode. It offers government the dependable policy it needs to deliver its Guarantee in an ever more volatile labour market.
Related Blogs
Disclaimer
The opinions expressed by our bloggers and those providing comments are personal, and may not necessarily reflect the opinions of Lancaster University. Responsibility for the accuracy of any of the information contained within blog posts belongs to the blogger.
Back to blog listing