Are we the baddies?
Posted on
© Paul Turner
British comedy duo Mitchell and Webb have a Second World War sketch where, dressed in Nazi SS uniforms expecting the advance of the Russians, one of them begins to question ‘Are we the baddies?’
Noticing the skulls on the badges on their caps, David Mitchell’s character doubts the motives of his side. ‘What do skulls make you think of?’ he asks. ‘Death, cannibals, beheading… pirates.’
This sketch came to mind at the recent Global Tipping Points Conference at Sunway University in Malaysia. Are businesses the baddies? As a parade of environmental and social scientists, health experts, politicians, and many more stepped on stage to discuss crucial issues facing the planet, business certainly did not come out of it well.
When there was talk of solutions and those who might provide them, business did not get a look in. There was mention of social movements, debates on political action, a push for scientific advances, behavioural changes, and more besides. It did not seem to be the ‘done thing’ to suggest that there are some corporations out there with a positive role to play, and who might provide the stimulus behind other actions.
The word ‘positive’ in the above sentence is a key one. For if business was not mentioned in terms of forward progress, it was certainly name-checked when it came to the problems we are facing when it comes to those global tipping points that were the focus of the gathering, and the negative actions that have taken us to the point where many of them have happened or are close to happening. Here, it was usually under the thinly-veiled insult of ‘vested interests’. Usually, this meant the fossil fuels industry.
I am not exactly what might be described as a vocal champion of oil and gas companies. They appear to be keen for us to keep on burning and forget about the damage it does. Maybe they would like us to forget alternatives such as wind, solar, even nuclear exist. But if I am no fan of their products, at the same time I do not hold them singularly responsible for all the problems we have in the world.
They are hardly alone in their exploitation of the Earth’s natural resources. Plenty of governments worldwide have profited from the sale of their fossil fuel supplies, there are many movements (with or without fossil fuel backing and influence) who would tell you climate change is a hoax. But in the eyes of those on stage in Malaysia, it seems that while governments and people as a whole can be trusted to have a change of heart and lead the charge to a brighter tomorrow, business cannot.
But here a whole swathe of people have been tarred with the same petroleum-coated brush. Because not all businesses have a couple of hundred oil derricks pumping 24 hours a day. Not all corporations drill baby, drill until the cows come home. Not all of them have spent decades digging up and burning coal seven days a week.
There are businesses that are leading the way in the transition to solar and wind power, from China to Denmark, the UK to Pakistan. These companies are at the cutting-edge of developments that are essential if we are to move to a less carbon intensive world. But among fascinating and engaging discussions on the stage in Malaysia, any credit they might get for such actions was lost in clouds of suspicion and a belief it was all about the money. I am no fool – despite what some people might have you believe. I know that businesses need to make money to have a future, but that does not mean they cannot have a broader purpose as well, one that aims at helping to address society’s ills. At least these people could see the economic benefits of going green – as opposed to some commentators on the recent COP31 gathering, and far beyond, who would have us believe everything comes down to a choice, destroy the planet and be rich, or save it and live in poverty.
It was different when we spoke to people individually at the conference. There, the important role that business has in resolving environmental and social issues was very much acknowledge, as was the possibility of business efforts taking us to new frontiers. Speaking to the likes of Dr Steve Smith, from the University of Exeter; Tamara Singh, from The Nature Conservancy in Singapore; and Professor Erik Berglöf, Director of the House of Governance and Public Policy at Stockholm School of Economics, we found them telling stories of where business has already set standards, or of where it has a key part to play.
Indeed, over the course of the last three years, we have spoken to many people on the Transforming Tomorrow podcast both from within and outside business organisations who have provided us with more positive examples than cannot be counted without numerous sets of fingers and toes.
We have heard from those whose companies treat staff welfare and sustainability practices with the utmost seriousness, and those who help to shape ideology and action across industries and sectors. We have spoken to people working in academia, society, and politics in countries around the world who give us examples where companies have set the standard and have pushed us further in the right direction.
Whether these are companies whose footprint is within their local community and region, or across continents, they can be a force for good. They do not have to sit in the trenches wondering if they are really the baddies.
Related Blogs
Disclaimer
The opinions expressed by our bloggers and those providing comments are personal, and may not necessarily reflect the opinions of Lancaster University. Responsibility for the accuracy of any of the information contained within blog posts belongs to the blogger.
Back to blog listing